Date: April 18, 1961 11:00AM
Location: Eagle River
Source: The Magonia compiled by Jacques Vallee and published in his book "Passport
to Magonia." Database entry number 517.
Details of Incident:
J. Simonton heard a whining sound and saw an object, 10 m in
diameter, 4 m high,
with exhaust pipes around the periphery, land near his house. A door
and a man appeared. About 1.50 m tall, he wore a black, turtle-neck
pullover with a white turtleneck belt, and black trousers with a
vertical white band along the side. Two figures were visible inside the
filled a jug with water, returned it to the man, who gave him three
pancakes, and the craft took off.
Source: The book entitled The W-Files written
by Jay Rath. Pages 1-6.
Wisconsin 's strangest close encounter of the third kind must surely be the incident during
which Joe Simonton was given three pancakes by "Italian-looking" aliens.
A close encounter of the
third kind is an actual meeting between humans and extraterrestrials, and Simonton's is easily the
state's best known. Despite the unlikely manner in which the story unfolded, the episode survived a
rigorous assessment by the U.S. Air Force and is carried in their files as "unexplained."
In 1961, Joe Simonton was a plumber; auctioneer and Santa Claus - annually, for the Eagle River
Chamber of Commerce. He reported his age as 55 or 60, depending on the interviewer: At 11 a.m.,
April 18, Simonton was having a late breakfast when he heard a sound like that of a jet being
throttled back, something like the sound of "knobby tires on wet pavement." He went into the yard and
saw a flying saucer drop out of the sky and hover over his farm. It was silver and "brighter than
chrome," 12 feet in height and 30 feet in diameter. On one edge were what appeared to be
exhaust pipes, 6 or 7 inches in diameter.
The disc landed and a hatch opened. Inside were three dark-skinned
aliens, each about 5 feet tall and weighing about 125 pounds. They
appeared to be between 25 and 30 years old and were dressed in dark
blue or black knit uniforms with
turtleneck tops, and helmet-like caps. They were clean-shaven, Simonton
The aliens did not speak in his presence, but they had a silvery jug with
two handles, heavier than aluminum but lighter than steel, about a foot high. It seemed to be
made out of the same material as the craft. Simonton said it was "a beautiful thing, a Thermos
jug-like bottle quite unlike any jug I have ever seen here [on Earth]."
Through ESP or something, Simonton got the idea that the aliens wanted water. He left the
visitors, filled the jug from the water pump in his basement, then returned to the craft and
gave the jug back. To do this, he had to brace himself against the UFO's hull and stretch up.
From the subsequent Air Force report: "Looking into the [saucer] he saw a man 'cooking' on some
kind of flameless cooking appliance." The alien was preparing pancakes.
The interior of the UFO was dull black, even the three "extremely beautiful" instrument
panels, and had the appearance of wrought iron. The contrast between the dark interior and shiny
exterior so fascinated Simonton that he later said that he "would love to have a room painted in
the same way."
In return for the water, one of the aliens - the only one with narrow red trim on his
trousers - presented Simonton with three of the pancakes, hot from the griddle. As he did so,
the alien touched his own forehead, apparently a salute in thanks to Simonton for his help.
Simonton saluted back. Each of the pancakes was roughly 3 inches in diameter and perforated
with small holes.
The head alien then connected a line or belt to a hook in his clothing and
the hatch closed. The saucer rose about 20 feet and took off to the south, at a 45-degree
angle. Its wake left a blast of air that tossed the tops of nearby pine trees. The craft took
only two seconds to disappear from view.
Simonton ate one of the pancakes, ostensibly in the interest of
science. "It tasted like cardboard," he told the Associated Press. The
other two pancakes he gave to Vilas County Judge Frank Carter, a local
UFO enthusiast. Carter, who called the aliens "saucernauts" ("I prefer
Italians"), said he believed Simonton's story since
he could not think of any way in which the farmer might profit from a
hoax. Carter's son,
Colyn, today a lawyer in Eagle River, told me, "I recall as a youngster
that my dad took it
Judge Carter sent the pancakes to what was then the country's top
investigative group, the National Investigations Committee on Aerial Phenomena (NICAP). They
refused the opportunity to check it out. That put a damper on Judge Carter's plans; he had
wanted to hold a seminar on the incident.
By this time, Simonton said, he was "irked by reporters making fun of the situation and laughing."
In response to all this, the Air Force dispatched its civilian UFO investigator, J. Allen Hynek.
Hynek at the time was an astronomer at Northwestern University. He later became convinced that
UFOs are real, and founded his own investigative agency, which took over NICAP's files after that
group folded. Thanks to Hynek, a Northwestern University committee and the Air Force's Technical
Intelligence Center analyzed one of Simonton's pancakes and found it to be made of flour, sugar and
grease; it was rumored, however, that the wheat in the pancakes was of an unknown type.
The official Air Force assessment of it all: This case is unexplained. "The only serious flaw
in the story is the disappearance of the craft in 'two seconds.' The rest of the story did not
contain any outrages to physical concepts," reads the report. Simonton "answered questions
directly, did not contradict himself, insisted on the facts being exactly as he stated and
refused to accept embellishments or modifications. He stated he was sure that we wouldn't
believe him but that he didn't care whether he was believed. He stated simply that this
happened and that was that."
The private Air Force response was unearthed after a little detective work. It comes
from a UFO handbook for Air Force personnel, written by Lloyd Mallan and issued in a popular
edition by Science and Mechanics Publishing Co. In the book, Mallan refers to "J.S., a highly
regarded, much respected citizen of Eagle River, Wis. -- a small rural community noted for its
attractiveness to tourists."
(Unless there are more space-pancake recipients in Eagle River than otherwise reported, we can
safely see through Mallan's clever attempt at disguise and positively identify "J.S." as Joe
One Air Force investigator, according to Mallan, said that Simonton "appeared quite sincere to me,
did not appear to be the perpetrator of a hoax." But an Air Force Aeronautical Systems Division
psychiatrist believed that Simonton had suffered a hallucination and subsequent delusion.
The Air Technical Intelligence Center investigator said, "cases of this type could be injurious to
the mental health of the individual if [he] became upset due to the experience. ...It was pointed
out that experiences of this type, hallucinations followed by delusion, are not at all uncommon and
especially in rural communities."
Additionally, according to Mallan, the Air Force took to heart an
unsubstantiated rumor circulated by, among others, Raymond Palmer, a publisher of pulp
flying-saucer and science-fiction magazines. Palmer reported to the Air Force his belief that
Simonton had been hypnotized by an Eagle River real estate broker and was fed the pancake
story so that he would repeat it and appear truthful. The motivation for this was economic,
for the purpose of "a miniature Disneyland that is or was being built in the area."
To understand how incredible the rumor was, it is useful to look at the credibility of Palmer
himself. One of his favorite theories was that flying saucers came from a secret hollow-Earth
civilization ruled by a race called Detrimental Robots, which he abbreviated as "Deros."
According to Palmer, the Deros manipulated humanity with their projected thought rays.
Palmer's primary source -- actually, his only source -- was a Pennsylvania welder who drew
upon "racial memory" for his accounts. (There apparently is no mention in Air Force files of
the possibility that the Deros' thought-ray had been turned upon real estate agents, or Palmer,
or even the Air Force, though I believe there is as much evidence for that as for an Eagle
But based on such sound "evidence," the Air Technical Intelligence
Center, which headquartered Air Force UFO investigations, let the matter drop. Publicly, it
was a mystery. The classified reason, revealed to Mallan, was that the Air Force would not
pursue the matter "due to the possibility of causing [Simonton] embarrassment which might
prove injurious to his health." This was an uncharacteristic kindness on the part of the Air
Force; they regularly had been dismissing reports from pilots - even their own - as
misidentifications or, worse, hallucinations. "There are sufficient psychological explanations
for reports not otherwise explainable," concluded the Psychology Branch of the Air Force's
Aeromedical Laboratory in 1949. Pilots, police, professors, besides regular folks -- all nuts.
In the 60's, though, for a brief, shining moment, the Air Force took on a human face and it
its collective tongue, bending over backwards to carry the case of a part-time Santa and
full-time chicken farmer as unexplained. Some may smell a conspiracy here.
As for Simonton himself, in the end he was left with a bitter taste in his mouth, and it wasn't
from the pancakes. "I haven't been able to work for three weeks," he told United Press International.
"I'm going to have to start making some money." He said that the next time he saw a flying
saucer he would keep it to himself.
He lied. In 1970 Simonton was visited by Lee Alexander,
a UFO enthusiast active in a Detroit-based investigative group. Simonton told Alexander that
he had had more visits from the aliens, but he had not told anyone because of the way his
first report had been received.
And that is all we know.
Disclaimer: UFOwisconsin.com has not
verified the validity of every UFO report published within UFOwisconsin.com.
All reports are added to the database 'as is' received. The sighting
reports posted have many possible explanations, including but not restricted to
stars, planets, airplanes, known natural earthly phenomena, hoaxes etc. We leave
it up to the individual viewer to judge the report based upon the content of the
report itself. As investigations occur, that information will be notated on the